Mike's Pies Inc
10350 Windhorst Road #100, Tampa
-
1/10/24 1st I had a pick up at this facility and I couldn’t figure out how to check in so I called and a nice lady pick up and assisted me, thank you! 2nd for all drivers in a truck and trailer Precool your reefer this is a frozen pickup, … More the street direction are correct turn on that little street and go all the way to the back where it dead ends and go to the docks at the far end! This was a simple in and out, excellent pick up!
Now 3rd I read the reviews and I knew I was picking up pies and that there would be cheese cake, I had my mouth on a key lime pie and blue berry but I settled for a key lime and salty caramel cheese cake! Yes they do retail in the front! I must say it’s well worth it! I shared with one of my customer and we were in heaven! -
I must be the only person who didn't know that Mike's Pies is hidden in an office/warehouse space on Windhorst near Falkenburg Road. They've been there for 3 years now. I was still getting their key lime pies at Winn-Dixie … More up until this past week. For those who are not local, they started their business in Tampa over 30 years ago. The pies can be found nationally at restaurants and grocery stores. They happened to be one of many contestants in a pie contest on GMA recently which prompted me to look up their address. They are closer than I thought.
As others have said, it's hidden. Thankfully I read the reviews stating that because it still took me a while to find it. I had also read that you need to call ahead if you want something specific, or during the holiday rush for pies. I went on a whim to see what they had available. They had many frozen pies, and I believe some were being held for pick up orders. She said there was one seasonal guava cheesecake left. At that point, I didn't even really care what other flavors they had. I think they had key lime, pecan, and others. It was guava that screamed the loudest to me. It was a very quick transaction after that. I was in and out in less than 5 minutes.
I kept it in the car for a while because I had other errands to run. It defrosted enough were I could pull out a slice of it and pop the rest into the freezer (yep, it can be refrozen). These cheesecakes are already pre-sliced which is very convenient. Mind you, these are larger than any of the Mike's Pies sold at grocery stores. There are 12 big slices in this cheesecake. I couldn't wait for my slice to defrost. I went ahead and ate it partially frozen. It was the best cheesecake ever! The guava is not just on top of it. It's mixed inside the cheese cake. It had guava in every bite. It ended up being so creamy towards the end as it continued to defrost. Maybe because I took my sweet time savoring each bite. I so wish this flavor was on their regular local menu. I remember seeing it on the menu at Fat Willie's Fish Camp back in September but they ran out of it. I feel like this cheesecake was meant for me to find. I will get it again whenever it's back on the local menu. This cheesecake will have to last until then. -
Not a retail location per se. It is a factory that sells a very limited offering from their office entrance. You can however get any item you want from their selection if you call 2 days ahead. My very first visit and my Apple Crisp pie … More was amazing. The pie and slices are huge. They ship all over the US and their pies can be frozen. Care and heating instructions provided. It's not easy to find so use GPS. When you arrive, it's the huge building on your left, no sign, entrance is around the front at the end of the parking lot. Masks required. A definite special occasions destination for me in the future. They close early at 4pm.
-
Dear God this is the best key lime pie you’ll ever taste. We’ve been getting these at Winn Dixie every time we come to Florida for decades. This pie is first on our grocery list. This is our second one this visit.
This pie is Florida in … More one bite but you’ll never stop at one bite 😉 -
I travel to Clanton from Tuscaloosa for work and ALWAYS stop at Pies By Mike. Everything they have is fantastic and the staff is equally amazing.
-
Best pie’s ever! I’m sure I’ve tired them all. Absolutely LOVE Mike’s Key-lime pie🤤! Wonderful family owned company. Highly recommended!!!
-
These pies are absolutely delicious! Have had several times, and have always been great!
-
The lady at the front desk actually waited past4pm to make sure my best friend got his Birthday Cheesecake.
Best pies/Cheesecakes ever -
The lady at the front desk actually waited past4pm to make sure my best friend got his Birthday Cheesecake.
Best pies/Cheesecakes ever -
Mike’s Pies is the most delicious desserts I have ever had. They are consistent every single slice. Red Velvet leaves your mouth watering for more.
-
Ordered the pinacolada pie.arrived and met a guy at the door..Turned out it was Mike from Mike's Pies.I introduced my wife and he asked if we wanted to go on a tour.We went in back and saw the workings of Mike's Pies.My wife and … More I had a blast.We received our pie and we left.Thank you Mike for taking the time.And lastly,the pie was fantastic and I should have bought two..
-
Their cheesecakes are simply delicious here and the service is always great too. I highly would recommend trying them out whenever you have a chance. They have so many pies to pick from!
-
Oh my! So very good!! We had the pleasure of having a slice of the key lime pie at Crabby's while visiting Clearwater, FL. Well, we found out who made it and when we were back home we ordered a whole pie and had it shipped.
-
I love Mike's Pies!! I am gluten free, and the flavors they have for me are FANTASTIC!! The receptionist was adorable and professional. The place was clean. I wish them all the success possible.
-
Ate their pie for the first time and it's really delicious . They have a pretty good menu and their prices ain't bad at all.
-
Order a few days ahead for pick up or take your chances with what is in the Oops Cooler. Plan well ahead of holidays if you want to be sure and have something.Dietary restrictions: This is what better restaurants serve.
-
Mike's is to pies as Bern's is to steak. These desserts are in a league of their own. With humble beginnings in South Tampa and now two moves later to a big, modern facility underscores the high quality and consistency of the … More pies, cakes and cheesecakes over time. Once you taste a Mike's dessert you'll find in difficult enjoy a supermarket bakery produced item. Yes, they are more expensive, but you get what you pay for.
-
This is the best key lime pie. They are known for it. Don't compromise. Get this one.Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes
Key Lime Pie …More -
The BEST Cheesecake!!!I've had several flavors, including the gluten free, and they are all good.
-
Awesome stuff. I have had a taste of several different ones and they are all good.
-
I watched GMA this morning and was thrilled to see Mike and his son representing all the years of fabulous baking!! I owned The Personal Touch Catering in St. Petersburg until I retired in 2007. From the very beginning of his company, he … More provided the best and yummy pies!! I provided my customers with the best and Mike's was the best pies then and so thrilled to see he is still the best and going with a younger generation too! Congratulations !! Very happy for you!!Midge Trubey
-
My mother was visiting and she’s gluten-free so I thought I’d treat her to the deep dish GF key lime pie. It’s delicious! We called ahead two days before to preorder and picked up on a Friday around 3pm. The location is confusing (like … More a warehouse area) drive around to the backside and you will see the entrance at the far end. Would order again!
-
Never been to your physical location. Had a slice of your red velvet cake at a restaurant my wife and I go to once in a while. I'm used to Publix being VERY sweet and was expecting that taste. Not at all. Your red velvet was the best … More I've ever had.
-
Great selection of desserts and excellent service! I was greeted and helped immediately by a very friendly and knowledgeable person. While he was getting my pie, everyone who happened to walk past me asked if I needed help. Impressive level … More of service! They also had a big selection of pie, cake and cheesecake onsite, perfect for a belated birthday treat!
-
I recently attended a wedding that was catered with Mike's Pies. What an awesome idea and loved by all (versus a dry cake). I had multiple opportunities to taste a plethora of pies (Key Lime, Orange Blossom and Salted Caramel were … More my personal favorites). This pie is well worth seeking out or ordering online. The cherry on the pie is that Mike and his staff are simply wonderful people and love what they do! Do yourself a favor and try this delicious pie.
-
Bought the Key Lime and Salted Caramel. Decadent and divine! So glad they only sell whole pies because now I can treat myself all month long. Definitely going back when visiting Tampa area.
-
Mike's pies have one of the best pies (cheese cakes, mud pies...etc) in FL hands down. My all time favorite is their rich salted caramel cheese cake.I should warn that their prices keep going up unfortunately!
-
I normally don’t post reviews but after having the pumpkin cheesecake from Mike’s Pies I have to just say that it was phenomenal. This huge pie only made it to this Monday because we devoured it. Highly recommend!!
-
How have I not known this place existed.I bought one of their key lime pies and it was amazing.I considered JJ Gandy's key lime pie to be the gold standard. This one was just as good and about half the price.I'm going back.
-
I did research all over Tampa Bay trying to find the best place for Thanksgiving pies. I can’t say how happy I am that I chose this place. Every single person said that each of the pies were the absolute best they’ve ever had. Not to mention … More the ordering process and picking up couldn’t have been easier. And it’s awesome to know you’re supporting a small local business. We will be back and I will be telling everyone about Mikes Pies!
-
Amazing Key Lime Pie-I found Mike's Key Lime Pie at the Winn-Dixie in Big Pine Key and absolutely loved it. The crust is moist and the pie has just enough tart flavor to keep me coming back. I have told all of my friends about it … More too so please keep the store stocked! I use to make my own but Mike's key lime is better than my own pie.
-
Picked up a large order from Mike's Pies and their products are always amazing, but had a little delay in the order. They went so far above and beyond to make up for the small inconvenience that I can not say enough about their stellar … More customer service! I will definitely return as a customer.
-
I was offered a free Thanksgivings pie from Mike’s Pies. I was a little skeptical about this, but after tasting my pie I want you to know that your southern pecan pie was the best one I’ve ever tasted! Needless to say I will be ordering … More this for Christmas!
-
Purchased the pie at my local Winn-Dixie and it was amazing!! Great price $7.99 for a whole pie. Taste and quality was well beyond what I was expecting for a tart and sweet cream pie.
-
Simply THE best Key Lime pie outside of Miami. The perfect balance of sweet and tart. The pie filling is creamy and rich and the crust offers a nice flaky taste. Great pies, great people, and great company!
-
Best pies to be found. They supply restaurants and gourmet eatries in many states and you can walk in to their Tampa facility and take one home to your own freezer. Killer Key Lime is a Florida must.. but don't miss the cheesecakes … More either
-
Got the killer key lime. Really, really good. Price is fair for the size. They are bigger than you would expect. Unless you have a serious sweet tooth, expect a pie to last a while. Or feed 12 people easily.
-
Just shared a piece of the Key Lime Pie with my husband on a vacation to Florida. We both agreed it was THE BEST Key Lime pie we’d ever tried! So so good! The crust is FABULOUS! Can this be mailed to Missouri? We hope so!
-
Mike's Pies the Best Pies and Cleanest Facility!Charles Melton is completely wrong and this is a form of slander! I invite anyone to come see our facility. Our facility is immaculate, and we make the best pies with the best ingredients. … More Charles,is a disgruntled applicant we did not hire. Has never been past the lobby.
-
The smell inside will make you want to spend your whole paycheck there. Quality of cakes and customer service are top notch!
-
We just finished Thanksgiving Dinner topped off with wonderful pies from Mike's Pies -- a cheesecake and a key lime pie. They were delicious, a real gourmet's delight. - Wally Williams, Suncoast RV Rental
-
I just had the Salted Caramel Cheesecake it was extremely good. Tampa is a little far to go for dessert but it is sooooo good!Going to make a trip there for the Holidays! Yummy!
-
I firmly believe that there is no other better pie. As a 30+ cook in the business. As a sous, kitchen manager at place's like Naples Ritz, Loew's Resorts and others. I always stress. Sell Mike's on the menu. And especially … More advertise it on the menu that it is Mike's. We can do alot in the kitchen but we certainly can't duplicate this superior product.
-
Chocolate mousse pie was outstanding.. everything looked delicious don’t be fooled if you go to the warehouse you can buy straight from there! Or in any store that carries them but just go there because they have all the options !
-
If you ever want to a piece of pie that is heaven and after its gone you keep thinking of it and you smack your lips then you need to go there. Also they are wonderful about giving to the veterans thanks to a wonderful staff and amazing … More pies n cakes.
-
Nice selection of pies. Friendly service. It is tricky to find. The entrance is tucked away on the side of the building facing I75.
-
Mike is awesome and his pies and cakes are the best I've ever had he really uses the best ingredients with all natural products if I could give 10 🌟 I would I recommend anyone that is looking for cake or pie good see him
-
Mike's Pies are matched only by the class and care of his busy staff who treat each customer like royalty, which only befits his grand and wondrous cuisine creations. A true national treasure of Tampa Bay.
-
I live in ky and I was given a blueberry cheesecake from mike's pies as a Christmas thank you gift. Excellent cheesecake though it's a little heavy on the blueberry.
-
The key lime will change your life. Only downside is, no other key lime will every be satisfying
-
The caramel ribbon cheesecake that was DONATED to our elementary school teacher appreciation luncheon was the BEST I've ever had. This was repeated by everyone else who had it. Phenomenal job.
-
The best place to buy cheesecake ♥️♥️♥️
-
Best key lime pie I've had, hands down. Brought some home to the family and we all agreed - the killer key lime is perfection!
-
THE BIGGEST AND BEST MADE PIES IN ALL OF FLORIDA! IT'S NO WONDER "WINGHOUSE" GETS THIER PIE-OF-THE-MONTH FROM MIKE'S! AND THE STAFF HERE IS AMAZING AND WILL WORK WITH YOU ON ANY ORDER.
-
I always grab a bunch of Mikes Pies for all my customers and they love em. I can't get threw any holiday with out them for my family. Love em Mike.Rollie, Cleveland , ohio
-
Your pumpkin cheesecake was a huge success today at Thanksgiving dinner! I now have the honor and duty of bringing this gem to the festivities every year! 🙂
-
I thought the crust could be a little better but the filling on there Key Lime pie was truly out of this world. Best Key Lime pie i have ever had.
-
Always delicious!! Was introduced during a food show. It's been history since.
-
The absolute best pies that I have ever had! I've had the Key Lime, Mississippi Mud, Reeses, & Buttermilk and highly recommend them all.
-
Delicious pies.... Favorite is the NY Cheesecake.
-
The best Key Lime pie in the world and its made right here in Tampa!
-
The pies are amazing and the people are great. They are in a business park but who cares...this is fantastic pie!! Best in Tampa Bay!!
-
Always a pleasure walking over and getting a pie from here. The best pie's in Tampa highly recommended 😊😊😊 Very friendly atmosphere and welcoming staff
-
Clean, fast and friendly. The Pumpkin Cheesecake is AMAZING!!!
-
There's simply no comparison in the tastes and quality of there pies/ cheesecakes/ cakes !I tell everyone about MIKE'S PIES!
-
A hidden gem. If you are looking for the best Pies in town you need to give them a try.
-
Freaking awesome....bring a paper towel with you...you will need it to clean your drool while looking at your choices...and the best part is they taste so damn good. Now I need to head there again right now
-
Incredible pies!!!! Have tried 6 different flavors and was never disappointed. Better than homemade.
-
Excellent and the ladies up front were very courteous and helpful. I was in and out thanks!
-
Every pie/cheesecake I've had have been beyond fantastic. The staff is incredibly nice
-
This is some of the best pies in Tampa. Been loving them for a few years now. Highly recommended
-
Best key lime pie I've ever had!
-
Very good pies, a little bit high on price, BUT THE REST IS BEYOND AMAZING!!! Love it everything!!
-
Fantastic pies. Impossible directions last quarter mile on Google maps. It's a wholesale location, not customer focused.
-
Best pies, cakes, and cheesecakes in Tampa Bay. One bite and you will be hooked for life!
-
Best pumpkin pie I’ve ever had by a looonnggg shot. I can’t wait to try all the others.
-
Great place to get desserts quality pies and they have amazing staff
-
They make the best 3 layer chocolate cake. It's really good
-
They make AMAZING pies, cakes & cheesecakes. Worth every penny.
-
Simply the best. Don't let the "pie" name fool you -- the cheesecakes are incredible, too!
-
We enjoy all the pies we have had from there!!!Can't go wrong with Mike's Pies
-
Best key lime pie in all of Florida!!
-
Omg the sea salt caramel cheesecake is to die for... Once it's gone you're gonna want another..
-
Warehouse, got in with my truck got loaded within 30 minutes nice people here
-
Thank you for having safe gluten free pies!! Future lifetime customer right here!!!
-
Great pies...awesome cheesecake and key lime!
-
Best pies and cakes around. Hard to find and away from anything, but worth looking for!
-
The best pies around! Everyone loved them.
-
I was a deliv.truck in here. Very fast unloadind easy to get there plenty of space to back up.
-
So good. Awesome products and a great local company you should be supporting.
-
Great pies. Clean place definitely recommend!
-
The cleanest place I've ever worked at. The best pies of the planet.
-
Their key lime pie is out of this world!
-
One of the best key lime pies I've ever had.
-
The cleanest and most organized warehouse I've ever seen.
-
There is no comparison. These pies are perfect!!!
-
Best cheesecake I've had in a long time
-
To many around town. To me Mike's are the best ones
-
Great p/u love the 5 dollar a pie deal for drivers
-
The best dang pies on the dang ol planet. Seriously, AMAZING!!
-
Gotta have Mike's pie! Worth the drive
-
Best key lime pie in town!
-
Best cheese cake
-
Friendly atmosphere and also give military discount
-
No one come close to mike’s pie.
-
Great customer service and delicious pies
-
Loved it .key lime was delicious.
-
They are great people and pie's...
-
Red velvet cake was amazing.
-
Nice place. Mean new building
-
New warehouse delivering ingredients
-
Friendly staff and great cheesecake!!!
-
Outstanding in all they do!
-
Damn good pies!
-
Great taste and very clean
-
Good pie!
-
Wow. What a wonderful place!
-
Blueberry cheesecake is fabulous!!!
-
Best pies on the planet
-
Southern Pecan awesome!
-
Great pie
-
The staff is really friendly.
-
Best Pie Place ever!
-
These pies are awesome
-
delicious! what more to say
-
Awesome place to work.
-
Best pecan pie !!!
-
Lo maximo...the best
-
Best decision EVER
-
Best pies in the world
-
Good
-
Awesome pies
-
Amazing
-
Excellent company
-
Really good
-
Pies are amazing
-
Keylime!!!!yummy
-
tasty pies!
-
Love, love, love
-
Amazing pies
-
-
love me
-
-
-
-
-
-
Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes
Key Lime Pie, Pecan Pie, Guava Cheesecake, Pumpkin Pie, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Apple Crisp PieMore -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes
Cheesecakes and Fruit for Topping, Pumpkin CheesecakeMore -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes
Strawberry 2 LayerMore -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Absolutely the best pies in central florida. Ive tried most of their pies, cakes and cheese cakes and not one has been anything short of spectacular! I could not recommend Mikes enough! Get their delivery and you wont be disappointed! … More
